A later look at Elemental: War of Magic

Nice write up, worth a read.  I wouldn't categorize the magic system as excellent though.  I liked being able to summon my own army early enough for it to make an impact (or for that matter really freeforming it researching a vast variety of spells right off the bat).  I do however love the terraforming spells and movement spells.  My biggest gripe comes from the fact that there are not too many useful tactical spells imo.  Even the straight damage spells are meh.  Some require having 2-3 of one shard to become really effective and it's hard enough to obtain 3-4 shards overall.  Not to mention that the damage potential of the tactical spells is no where near the damage of say, the war axe since you would get multiple attacks with the weapon (requires positioning and melee range however) but all your attack points are drained after casting one spell.  Other then the "support" spells I feel the entire magic system as a means to bypass a sub par military just does not work. 

I still play this game fairly regularly, however the more I play the more I want it to be a better game overall.  The few things it does right is covered in mounds of bleh gameplay. 

I really believe that E:WoM and the coming FE can expand upon the 4x genre in ways no other 4x game has (note: these thoughts stem from a single player version of the game only).  The concept behind the original version of the game (the one released last August) is still in tact in that theres more of a sandbox feel to the game, you don't have to follow one or two optimal routes for victory, you can really play the game how you want.  The functions of the techs would open up even more gameplay opportunities, this is important for the longevity of the game.  Within the same spirit of researching for more "advanced" resources and "advanced goody huts/dungeons, I'd like to see the game expanded so that when you do embark on a new quest or delve into a new dungeon the option to play as your hero from an RPG perspective is available.  For me, this would ultimately lead to the ability to actually traverse your kingdom/empire from a first/third person view and play a separate, more intimate version of the game.  Who said 4x games HAVE to all be alike in that the primary focus is on empire building.  I do believe that is one of, if not the most important aspect of a 4x game.  HOWEVER, if the gameplay was expanded to allow you to take control of your sovereign and party in a more traditional RPG aspect at certain times and for certain events/locations,  I think the game would succeed far more then if it were to continue to be an empire builder only.

With some of the ideas I've read about being implemented in FE I can see there being a road leading to more dynamic gameplay options within the overall game itself.  These are a few ideas to really make the game memorable imo.  Of course, the core gameplay needs to function properly first, then all the shiny cool new stuff can be added on to that.

Fair review.  Thanks for finding it.

Since 1.2a is the "first" release of the game, it would have been nice to mention 1.3.

Reading the review I want to try this game again. I could not "get" into it, did not feel it is as fun as GalCiv2 and even Civ 5 was better. May be it is time to try it again.

As for post above me by Solymer89, I like the idea of Diablo/Elemental hybrid. That would be fantastic! It always bothers me that in Diablo style games, the stuff you do for character development is very very insignificant time-wise. Like you play 1 hour dungeon, got a level up and some cool armor. It takes 10s to chose new level statistics and may be another 30s to re-arrange the armor. And that's it! Would be nicer if whatever you have got in dungeon you could use to do something, like building your cities and managing them. That would be effectively your leveling (of yourself and of civilization that provides you with better armor, ammo, weapons and even party members for your quests).

At the same time I do want to have a deep detailed version of strategy only game, because no matter how you try, when you have those hybrid games, the strategy layers suffer.

The dungeon hybrid does sound interesting. It would be a lot of fun but I suppose it will have to be in a different game. I've not played it but isn't that what Disciples 3 aspires to be?

I'm reinstalling E:WoM too. I was just going to wait for 1.3 but I'll give it another go.

The problem I keep having is that the early game feels very, very slow to me.  Maybe that's just me and my focus on techs.  But techs power everything, here, and it's very slow to start going down those trees.  So those first however many turns, I feel like I'm sort of flailing around, dropping a few huts and just, well, not really developing or changing at all.  It's frustrating.  Then, there's a critical mass point at which things come together and suddenly you feel like you can arm your armies and cast some spells and such.  But it takes so long!  Am I just doing it wrong?