MarkSaffian

I didn't see all of the items you mentioned, but I amazingly found what I was looking for! I clicked on "Configure enhanced taskbar..." I then went into the top item, "Taskbar button combining" and selected "Always combine taskbar buttons". With that, my personally made icons are remaining when items get opened (the line under each icon says it's open): <img src="https://cdn.stardock.us/forums/75/3/7503965/01c457dd-fdbc-47dd-84c5-04d0bbbeb

Yes, the Enhanced taskbar is set: I have Windows 11: Start11 version: <img src="https://cdn.stardock.us/forums/75/3/7503965/d6713e8b-7070-4345-9807-bc2c20b48e8f.

I reinstalled Start 11 because I changed my email and I needed a new account. Me previous Start 11 allowed me to set taskbar icons and they were always shown how I set them. But now, they change when every app is opened. Here's a simple example: Here's my email icon on the taskbar when it's closed (I made this icon): <img src="https://cdn.stardock.us/forums/75/3/7503965/9a630f65-67b5-488b-9a73-741ab9fe72