Incredible, my icons ripped in OSX! Oh my... a OSX.RIP!!

Today, i waked up with 5 e-mails noticing about a rip of my icons.
The ripper is mr Deggy, the webmaster of OSXP.NET.
He uploaded a iconset called Funky, using my icons and Hein icons, in two places:
-In their website, www.osxp.net , writing he (osxp) created the icons.
-In Resexcellence, www.resexcellence.com , here the direct download: http://www.resexcellence.com/archive_icons_01/downloads/12-30-02_Funky1Folder.sit

Actually the Noia icons are under GPL. This means everybody can use, modify and distribute the icons without request permission for it. But, it must: Post the GPL text (with the GPL explanation), write the modifications done, post credit to the original author and any other author ho made previous changes. He (mr Deggy) don't did any of these things. Sometimes, the new uploader don't like to post the GPL text file, but it always request permission to the original author, and post full credits to he/she (Name, and web adress where can be obtained the original icons); i guess this is the case of ObjectDock using the Eeveraldo's icons, and i think this is very correct (let me know if i'm wrong about the use of Eeveraldo's icons, Brad, i don't wish to make a big mistake).
Mr Deggy never solicited permission, and he posted a Readme.rtf file in the download that contains: 'Additional icons constructed on the original Noia ones to add many apps. Please credit the original author'
My name is not 'the original author'. My name is Carles Carbonell, or Carlitus, and my website is www.carlitus.net. In adition, this message have implicit the mr Degg sense of responsability about the work of others.
This is not the first time the Noia icons are ripped, but YES the most WRONG. Specially, comming from OSX!!!!


Powered by SkinBrowser!
6,355 views 14 replies
Reply #1 Top
Message as sent to 'Webmaster'...

https://www.wincustomize.com/msgboard.asp?BID=WC&id=88981

Carlitus....[Carles Carbonell] is concerned that you have used/modified his icons without permission and/or appropriate recognition/credit.
This is copyright theft, and frowned-upon by the graphic/skinning community at large.
I'd strongly suggest you correct this situation to everyone's satisfaction as adverse,tainted reputations regarding such things will adversely affect your current/future regard in the online graphic art community.

I await your favourable response.
Paul Martin
JAFO
Admin Wincustomize.com
Senior member DeviantART.com
Reply #2 Top
Thanks Paul.
As usual, you always helps the skinners
We (and personally me) feel more comfortable with friends like you.
I never understand the rippers mind. >
Reply #3 Top
No problem, Carles...always glad to help...
Reply #4 Top
Hope this is settled.
Reply #5 Top
The inconset uploaded in Resexcellence is removed.
I received a favorable answer from Resexcellence. Thanks to their team!
Reply #6 Top
There is justice after all.

Powered by SkinBrowser!
Reply #7 Top
Good to see...
Reply #8 Top
Reply #12 Top
Ok, mnore goos news.
The author communicated with me and expressed the best intentions.
I allow any use of my graphics when credits are explicits and/or the uploader follows the copyright/license policies.
He will post credits, and now, this case is clossed.
Please, don't send-me more emails about this case, i'm noticed about it (and mr Deggy) and it is nearly solved). It finished with understanding of both parts. He can use my icons, and the iconset will have correct credits.
End
Reply #13 Top
Thats great. Another happy ending.

Powered by SkinBrowser!
Reply #14 Top
Careful wording of a communication of complaint usually works....