Some initial reviews
from 
Elemental Forums
Elemental Forums
Just had a quick look at Metacritic.com to see if any reviews have been lodged yet.
So far not looking good. 
This one is a french site so is translated: Gamekult. Rating of 30%.
Review from 1up. Rating of 58%
In two weeks time the Three Moves Ahead team will be devoting their full podcast to Elemental and I think they are getting Brad in the week after to discuss it (Tom Chick is a regular panelist here).