I would agree it's normally the game's responsibility to handle that; however, uninstalling Start11 is what fixed it. Here is some additional info:
Windows 24H2 OS Build 26100.2314
Start11 version was 2.11 with the Trial license
I have Fences 5 installed as well, but that is not causing any issues.
I tried a reboot, reinstall, and resetting my settings to default.
Info about settings:
Windows Pro Style
I had turned on the Enhance the taskbar option; however, I turned that off as I also had an issue with the Windows button being moved to the left side of the task bar.