3D

Now, if you really think about it, you can't have 3D on a 2D screen. I noticed, Wincustomize is asking about 3D. There is no such thing on a 2D screen. I know everyone calls it 3D, but our kids are gonna grow up thinking 3D is flat. Oh well, just a thought. Peace. Hippie
9,194 views 38 replies
Reply #1 Top
We need holographics gui's.

If you think about it, your eyes don't see 3D either. The image is projected as a flat image on tyour retina and only after the brain does its image processing magic, do you perceive it as 3D.

Even worse, I'd say that 3D can only exist in a 4D world, for you need time to be able to see a 3D object form different angles. You can't do that from an instant.

/me is in a philosophic mood
Reply #2 Top
Finally. Intelligence. There is life, thinking life, out there. Very good. Peace. Hippie
Reply #3 Top
Sooo, to continue and loop this back to where we took off. If we can somehow let the screen display things at different angels, depending on which angle we are looking at it, it's visually as 3D as the real thing.

We'd only need a device to determine what angle we are staring at the screen and software that will determine and draw the gui at the correct angle.

/me think he's been intelligent enough for today
Reply #4 Top
actually you can trick your mind because it makes objects appear 3d because you have two eyes. they both see slightly different things, and your mind merges them to form 1 semi-3d visualization of the world. The goggles for 3d simulators work on this factor, and so do the 3d pictures and glasses (red/blue and the such). I don't know how you could emulate this on a flat screen but supposed sharp has: http://zdnet.com.com/2100-1103-978499.html

Reply #5 Top
craeonics - there is a screen being developed which does just that. Based on the same sort of technique as those flip cards with 3d looking pictures on (in?) which used to be given away with breakfast cereals. It may never turn into a real product though as holographic projection may well deliver soon enough to usurp it.

...and you can of course have stereoscopic glasses now (either the LCD alternating eye type, or with 2 displays built into them) - these can be linked to a VR set up which monitors head movement etc to create a 3d (4d as you noted) environment.

...the bit that's missing isn't the display devices - it's the OS which supports them Microsoft used to have a whole sub site dedicated to their work investigating adding a 3d metaphor to the desktop - last time I looked though it had been removed. It was looking dated though.
Reply #6 Top
Ohhh, ta kongit...I didn't realise Sharpe are that close to turning it into a commercial product
Reply #7 Top
look at the date on the article sput. have you seen a 3d monitor yet?
Reply #8 Top
if a person is blind all his life, and at a late age, his vision "returns" to him, he well see the world in 2d, his brain has not learned to cope with the 3rd dimension yet. this has proved to be true with some cases where peoples vision was restored to them electronically and naturally
Reply #9 Top
Take a look at this demo. Sun is working on a project called 'Looking Glass' that has some pretty good 3D effects with the desktop.

http://wwws.sun.com/software/looking_glass/demo.html
Reply #10 Top
...and of course, people with only 1 eye don't see steroscopically. It can be said that they can still see "in 3d" however as depth perception is also clued by the depth of field of the eye and the lens adjustments needed to focus on something.

<= deliberate smiley

kongit - I didn't notice the date...I was fooled by the fact that I read about this technology being developed recently so I thought this was a new announcement...that'll teach me to check sources more carfully!
Reply #11 Top
..wow..

War, murder, rape, drugs, poverty and worrying about my children knowing what is 3 Dimensional and what is a 3D representation on a 2d monitor is ah issue?



Hell I just hope that 70% of the kids in school can spell 3 Dimensional let alone know what it is
Reply #12 Top
pictoratus - ta for the link. I'd not seen this from Sun before. It looks nice, but I think it's a little disengenuous of them to assert that "the dominant desktop supplier" doesn't want people to see it as I know that MS are working on similarly extending the desktop into 3d and have been for many years....admittedly, they've yet to deliver anything to the user, but I understand that Stardock are pretty excited by some of the things they've been privy to as MS partners
Reply #13 Top
IPLural - I'd be happy is 70% of them knew what 70% means
Reply #14 Top
depth, thats it, thats the 3 dimension, right?
Reply #16 Top
I knew the world was flat

If you think about it, your eyes don't see 3D either. The image is projected as a flat image on tyour retina and only after the brain does its image processing magic, do you perceive it as 3D.


Reply #18 Top
#12 by Skinner Sput - 2/18/2004 5:54:45 PM


Whoever comes out with this type of desktop manipulation, be it Sun, Microsoft, (personally I'd like to see Stardock beat them to the punch), it will be a leap forward.
Reply #19 Top
it will be a leap forward.


as opposed to left/right or up/down?
Reply #20 Top
as opposed to left/right or up/down?


or upside down/inside out
Reply #21 Top

Gosh there's some odd perceptions of what is reality in this world.

Eddy Kay Shun is a good thing if ever undertaken...

Reply #22 Top
Eddy Kay Shun is a good thing if ever undertaken


Aww, that takes all the fun out of it

Much better to be unencumbered by reason.
Reply #23 Top

Perspective has been understood for thousands of years, and yet is the 'youngest' form of mathematical 'geometry' to be formally definable.

The depiction of a 3 dimensional object by mathematical/technical draughting as a two dimensional image is not much more than a century old.....but is crucial in Architecture [though these days ACAD software 'cheats' instead]....

Reply #24 Top
WOW. I just had a little thought, didn't mean to start an international uproar. And by the way, you're mind is tricked everyday. Whether watching TV, or listening to music, or just sitting there goig duh!. That's my favorite part. DUH! Peace. Hippie
Reply #25 Top
yeah, we actually see the world upside down, its just that thanks to the eye, the image is flipped around and our brain is taught to read it.

it will be a leap forward. as opposed to left/right or up/down?