Putting my money where my mouth is - literally

Recently I somewhat scolded another JU member (one that is known to rant on and on endlessly about the evils that are being perpetuated by our current President....) for having the audacity to bash the current Pres. for proposals to increase CAFE type standards that are imposed upon automotive manufacturers in the U.S.A. while that same JU member was likely riding around in a gas guzzler...

At the time I wrote my response, I too would have been riding around in something that would be considered a gas guzzler - a 2000 Ford Explorer that I got used a little more than a year ago. I liked my Explorer as it was a comfortable and quiet vehicle to drive. It had a lot of room for myself and my passengers to sit comfortably, and had plenty of room for hauling around equipment as necessary for work, or for my personal needs. Unfortunately though, my Explorer, like all but the newest ones, was not a gas sipping vehicle. It would get (on a good day) about 18 mpg. On most days, with normal driving, it would see about 16 mpg.

While my driving habits were pretty much to and from work and I had reduced unnecessary trips to a minimum, I still didn't like paying to fill the tank on my Explorer, and because of that I went out searching for a replacement this last weekend.

What I settled on is imaged below.

(Pontiac Vibe 2005 model year - Image linked from Edmunds.com site)

I looked long and hard for what to replace the Explorer with. I considered many different vehicles and looked at a few different dealers. Eventually, as luck would have it, I settled at a neighborhood dealer looking at the new Dodge Calibres. Unfortunately they are too new, in short supply, and what was available at the time didn't really fit my wants (at very basic model with no power locks/windows, etc.).

Keeping with my desires to minimize the damage that I'd be doing to my wallet by trading away a vehicle I still owed more money on than I'd get in trade, I looked for other alternatives, including used vehicles at the dealer. It was there that I found my match in the form of the Pontiac Vibe (sample image shown above).

I'm hoping that I haven't made a huge mistake, trading away low payments and high fuel costs for higher payments and lower fuel costs, but I think things will work out well for me.

The Vibe is rated at between 29 and 36 mpg (for details on fuel economy ratings for just about any vehicle, see this link: FuelEconomy.gov site), and realistic estimates are at the 32 mpg mark. That's a very reasonable number for me, since it effectively doubles my previous mileage, halving my fuel costs. (Which unfortunately slipped right into my monthly payment).

I do benefit by having a much newer vehicle, with lower existing miles on it (20k versus the 109k on the truck). I gain approximately 1 year or 13000 (give or take) miles worth of warranty on the new vehicle, and the world will hopefully benefit from the lower emissions (already Ultra Low Emissions Vehicle ready) that will be produced by my new ride. (For more details on the Vibe, see this link: Edmunds.com or this one: automotive.com review) I also gain the use of a vehicle that is a sister vehicle to the Toyota Matrix and is made for Pontiac by Toyota -- something that I'm told means I'll have a very reliable vehicle.

I sincerely wish I could have made the jump to an even more fuel efficient vehicle -- as an example the Honda Civic hybrid, or perhaps the Toyota Prius (or as some friends call it - the "pious") -- but the costs for those are just too great to bear at this point, at least with an existing debt on my older vehicle.

For the next few years (actually for as long as I'm making payments) I'll be sticking with the Vibe. It seems like it'll be great for my to and from work drive, and the increased fuel efficiency (compared to the old ride) will definitely help save money in the long run. At least people won't be able to say I didn't put my own money where my mouth was during that time.
4,663 views 4 replies
Reply #1 Top
I'm hoping that I haven't made a huge mistake, trading away low payments and high fuel costs for higher payments and lower fuel costs, but I think things will work out well for me.


We did the same thing over a year ago. We traded in a Oldsmobile Silhouette minivan @ $328/mo. for a Chevy Malibu sedan @ $425/mo. (a portion of that jump is negative equity, tho).

We switched insurance companies from Allstate to USAA, and while there are definite fuel savings, that insurance switch alone was enough to absorb that extra hundred bucks and make our auto expenses the same or less than before.

Annnnnyways...I don't know why I'm sharing all this. Haha.

The Vibe is a cute car. What color did you get?
Reply #2 Top
The Vibe is a cute car. What color did you get?


Thanks for the comments and the inquiry.

Blue was the color. Had a choice of both blue or red on the lot actually. The blue had the plastic trim around the windows that let you crack them without water coming in when raining, etc. Just a little more "loaded" than the red.

Red also being a somewhat favorite target of the Radar Jock cops, I went for the blue.

Oh, the blue that I got also is solid blue, meaning the lower panels are the same color, not the black/dark gray plastic. The Explorer had the plastic trim around the wheels and such and it just tends to get dull looking unless you use a lot of the Tire black or Armorall type products on it. Since I'm notoriously cheap and somewhat lazy, I figured better to go with the more solid metal (looking?) trim work.


Understand where you are coming from on the negative equity. My purchase price included about $1800 of same Not something I like doing, but my recent fill-ups at the pump were literally kickin' my butt. Again, I've probably traded off the cost at the pump to my bank, but I'll go with it for now.


Insurance wise, I was a bit surprised that Geico (the gecko folks) told me I'd be on the hook for about $100 more every six mo.'s for the Vibe. I was hoping it would be more of a wash. It may inspire me to shop around a bit, but again, I'm lazy, so who knows there.
Reply #3 Top
I am not going to give up my pickup! Besides, it is the Tacoma, not the Tundra, so it gets pretty good mileage.
Reply #4 Top
I am not going to give up my pickup!


I really didn't want to give up the Explorer either, or at least I didn't want to move away from a truck type vehicle. I looked hard at a couple of used Escape/Mazda Tribute type vehicles but they were over-priced (thanks for nothing Carmax!) and a bit too used for my tastes.

Unfortunately I really couldn't afford to do a new one of either type, though I see that Ford has new incentives coming out now that would help (help some, but not enough to make a difference).

So, at this point I'll enjoy the Vibe for the next several years, pay it off and eventually trade it a small truck. Perhaps even a hybrid or other "super fuel efficient" Escape or Saturn Vue type.