pfft, star wars ships are all flash and over compensating by size

id much rather a smaller, much higher tech ship

i mean, 1 or 2 (2 if you want to leave nothing left) Mk9 Naquadria enhanced nuclear weapons from Stargate, beamed aboard using Stargate beaming tech or even Star trek beam tech would drill the super star destroyer.

technology, abilities, and technological superiority are the way to go baby

cute, and up until the force thing, very accurate. Ship to ship the Federation would drill the Empire hands down. plus, if Picard hadnt answered that Com, nothing would have happened so after a few losses, protocol would have been to shoot first and ask questions later

im not sure if i would choose an older style battleship (i.e. yamamoto or bismarck) or a modern day cruiser... (most navies decomissioned their battleships because guns are obsolete compared to missiles etc) i mean, a harpoon anti-ship missile is more accurate and outranges even a 16 or 19 inch cannon so...

also, there is more armor on a modern day ship, as well as point defense cannons that could deal with incoming fire...

Read a book called "Weapons of Choice: World War 2.5"

i cant remember who wrote it, but its very interesting, its about an international naval fleet from about 100 years in the future that gets accidentally  sent back in time to just before the battle of midway

the technology in that book is quite impressive

but playful "Star Trek PWNS Star Wars" tirades are okay?

Trek > Wars. Especially if you count the last 20 years of Wars.

I dispise only Trek, so you can imagine what a bonus it was when the Enterprise lost.

pfft, the Enterprise lost because the empire chimed in from nowhere, and Vader used his stupid force powers. i mean, he needed the Enterprise to answer his damn phone call in the first place! =P

besides, if it was shoot first and ask questions later, i dont think Star Wars Repulsor Shields could withstand an assault from Star Trek particle cannons and photon torpedos

Star Trek FTW!

Archangel from Gundam SEED

 you all forget that star wars was thought of from the anti balistic missle system that the US told teh USSR could shoot down anything anyone launched. so star wars was created within logical tech as star trek is pure hoping and wishing. which means STAR WARS FTW!!!!   lol

to add to Moosters comments, there is a book by a respected Science Fiction write called Heinlien who wrote a book called Footfall.

In that book aliens came and invaded earth yada yada you know the story, important thing is when the Americans wanted to counter attack, or even wanted intelligence, they grabbed a bunch of Sci-Fi writers and put them into a thinktank

Now, i know thats a story, and not real, but then what do you think a Thinktank is?

Also, the US Gov didnt called it Star Wars, it was dubbed that by the public who like to name things...

Star Wars the movie was first released in 1977, while the Strategic Defense Initiative (or the Star Wars project) was created in 1983

which means you Fail, thanks for playing though

Notes: The Krenim temporal weapon ship was built at the height of the Krenim Imperium over two hundred years ago. This ship is impervious to any conventional weapons as it is phased out of normal time-space, the ship is also protected from changes in the timeline and the crew's aging was halted. On the weapon ship's first mission the creator and captain, Annorax, used ships temporal weapons to erase the Imperium's enemies from history. Due to a temporal miscalculation the Krenim Imperium collapsed and Annorax spent the next 200 years trying to restore the Imperium creating and erasing hundreds of species from history. The U.S.S. Voyager first encountered the temporal ship when trying to cross Krenim space after developing temporal shielding. Voyager itself was used to ram the temporal ship after a mutinous crew phased the ship back into normal ship. With the sacrifice of Voyager the temporal ship itself was erased from history and the timeline restored.

And, of course, SW weapons are ineffective vs. ST shields