I turned my overscan down all the way and set the format of my TV to 1:1. Still have the bottom of the screen cropped off on the lowest resolution settings, and the mouse cursor is off by about an inch. This game and Civ 5 give me all sorts of trouble, but at least I can play that one in windowed mode.
I guess I could pull out my old dell monitor and VGA cable, but I just think it's ridiculous that the game can't auto config to my resolution settings.
Thanks for the help guys.