Indeed the Rook's hammer is far more balanced. It requires a slight edge of skill to enable you to do any serious damage.
For the TB i actually quite like frost. I spec so that i'm full frost, without permafrost, go full in fireball to, and then get the end bonus + if you dont take any attributes from your bottom line you can get his fire nova thing to full as well. Which leads to complicated, but nice Demigod kills.
Rain of frost - Frost Nova - Deep freeze = with my spec thats doing around 2600 damage (cant remember the exact number of RoF) + your getting a 3 second stun, they've slowed by 30% and their attack speed is down by a similar number.
You can subsequently switch into fire, giving yourself +50% mana regen and enabling you to fireball them for 1350 dmg and then fire nova'ing for around 800.
Adds up to about 5k damage basically (number are a bit off i know)
It requires a lot of work, and you need some awesome mana regen to make him effective but i like it. That spec also means i have no auras, but i dont think they're that great unless there are large teams on the field.
My only complaint is that at lower levels he gets annihilated by any melee Demigod because of his minute health, its about half of Rook's.
EDIT: On the idea of heat doing extra damage for shatter = i don't really think its viable. It would mean that your constantly switching between your two forms and i dont think the frost nova stun would still be on them by the time you've managed to throw fireball.